SG-1 vs Atlantis vs Universe: stake your flag
-
Alright, the question that splits every Stargate room I have ever been in: SG-1, Atlantis, or Universe. One of them is your favorite. You know which.
SG-1
I will plant my flag and say SG-1, but not for the reasons people usually give. It is not just the run time, though ten seasons buys you a lot of room to grow. It is that the show let its premise breathe. The early military procedural thing slowly turned into this huge galactic mythology without ever forgetting it started as four people walking through a puddle into the unknown. And the cast got so comfortable with each other that the banter stopped feeling written. By the middle seasons they were just hanging out and we got to watch.
That said, I am not going to pretend the other two do not have the goods.
Atlantis
Atlantis nailed something SG-1 never quite did, which is the feeling of being cut off and outgunned in a place that is genuinely not yours. New galaxy, no backup, an enemy that actually scared you. The Wraith are one of the better threats the franchise ever built. When Atlantis was on, it was on.
Universe
Universe gets the most unfair treatment of the three. It went somewhere darker and quieter and a lot of people checked out because it was not the show they signed up for. But the ship itself as a character, the sense of being stuck with people you did not choose, the slow-burn dread of it. There is a version of fandom history where that show got its proper ending and we talk about it very differently now.
So that is my honest, slightly biased take. SG-1 by a nose, with full respect to the other two.
Here is the real question though. Forget which one is objectively best. Which one did you fall for first, and did it stay your favorite, or did one of the others sneak up and overtake it later?
Janus
